Review: Barbie Rewind

Preserving attitudes as well as games, Digital Eclipse turn in something really interesting.

Game preservation seems to have become something of a sticky, thorny subject. Naturally I'm all for it, in theory. But what is it? What actually constitutes "game preservation"? Encasing floppy disks full of NES roms in carbonite? Getting a copy of every game ever made into some kind of museum? Who maintains all of that? What happens when the nukes drop? Yes, I realise that is quite facetious, but let me put this radical concept to you: some things are and should be ephemeral. Their time passes, as do you. As shall we all, into the great void that is death. There's no afterlife, kids, we all just stop. Nah, I'm joking. Whatever you believe about death is definitely true.

"What's the point of all this, Stu?" you are definitely now asking. "Are you, in fact, advocating against the preservation of games?" No, no, no, no, no. Imagine being part of Retronauts and doing that! I'd have to be quite disingenuous, hmm? But no, absolutely not. I am simply asking aloud what game preservation actually is, in order to lead into a rather positive write-up of Barbie Rewind, a new compilation from my beloved Digital Eclipse. Because I'm sure that there are many out there who would wrinkle their noses at this software. Look, just... hear me out, okay? I think it's fair to say that none of the games presented in this compilation are particularly good, while several of them are completely wretched. But that's not the point, and Digital Eclipse, as ever, understand this.

She's literally me.
She's literally me.

That's nothing against Barbie, conceptually. I didn't play with dolls when I was a kid because I wasn't supposed to. Thanks, societal norms. God knows I played with my Monster in my Pockets, god knows I play with the monster in my pocket now when I think nobody's looking. Monsters are cool, you see. Barbie wasn't. Nor were Polly Pocket or Sindy. In fact, my understanding is that Sindy was the GoBots to Barbie's Transformers. Did that sentence make any sense whatsoever? At any rate, Barbie has enjoyed a bit of cultural renaissance thanks to Greta Gerwig's highly-acclaimed Barbie movie. I didn't care for it, but it wasn't for me, was it? Not for heteronormative cis male Stu. That probably seems like I'm being snarky; I assure you, I am not. Courting an audience besides people like me was the objective, one that - based on the film's wildly positive reception - it achieved admirably.

It's a good time, then, to release a collection of 17 old Barbie video games, all of which I can recall being fiercely maligned at their time of release by the extremely testosterone-rich games press of yore. Not like now, of course, where everything is absolutely fine. But we're talking about the era of even Nintendo advertising Ocarina of Time with "Willst thou get the girl? Or play like one?" Not to put too fine a point on it, but gaming was a boy's club. Still is, obviously. But back then I suppose at the very least there wasn't Twitter, or X, or whatever that lunatic is calling it now. Point of order, however! Game preservation! Let's say, for the sake of argument, that making a game available on modern platforms constitutes its preservation. If that's true, then Digital Eclipse has quite plainly preserved these Barbie games. Good on them, because preservation is all-or-nothing and it seems more important than ever to show that gaming, however clumsily, has always catered for an audience besides dudes.

The really rather good Secret Agent Barbie.
The really rather decent Secret Agent Barbie.

Are the games good? Like I said, that really doesn't matter. I'd say it's probably the least important thing to take into account when preserving them. We can't pick and choose, it's gotta be everything, and this is a solid clutch of stuff that I would never in a million years think anybody would have bothered with. No, the games aren't good. Some are better than others. I won't list all seventeen, but I will alert you to the pinnacles and nadirs. From this lot, I would say that the NES Barbie is a puzzle platformer that's better than it initially seems, but the Game Boy version - cleverly titled Barbie Game Girl - is surprisingly fun. I mean, yes, it's me, but I liked it fine. It reminded me of Bart Vs. The Space Mutants thanks to an appealing mixture of simplicity and mild puzzling, while the graphics were clear and readable.

Barbie Super Model, however, is very bad. It also feels a little condescending in a way the previous two games just weren't. Barbie drives her stupid car at about one mile per hour, pausing only to duck into risible mini-games like "match her outfit with the magazine cover" that nobody could possibly fail. Because... it's for girls, right? It's a preservation of cultural stupidity as well as of bits and bytes, which demonstrates the malaise which Gerwig's Barbie worked hard to evaporate. There's historical value in preserving that. This and future generations should see how hard these games patronised 50% of the human race.

The previously unreleased (cool!) Barbie Vacation Adventure is, somehow, even worse - the slowest, least interesting and most supercilious (least cilious?) point and click adventure I've ever experienced. Also terrible is Adventures With Barbie: Ocean Discovery. When one of your mini-games is a jigsaw, it gives the impression that you don't have any ideas at all. Barbie Horse Adventures didn't really ring my bell, either, but I did enjoy the hypnotically flowing mane as you undergo the FMV-esque riding segment. I tried to steer my horse to leap over the fence and head for the nearest gully, but the game would not allow me to commit suicide by equine.

An unexpected cameo appearance by James Rolfe.
An unexpected cameo appearance by James Rolfe.

After playing a bunch more titles, two of which featured matching memory cards, for god's sake, it only reinforced my notion that I was playing through a cultural history of talking down to girls. I'm not directing this criticism at the developers, or the publishers, or anyone, really. It's a series of snapshots of intellectually dishonest under-thumbing that bends over backwards to reinforce the imposition of specific roles onto this gender. I'm getting political, I know, but it is what it is and I started to find the experience all the more fascinating. The collection of supplementary material found in this package makes this world all the more complete and all the more potentially stifling. It has to be said. Possibly not by me, but... hey, there's a whole hit movie about this. I'm just picking up what they're putting down.

Thankfully Secret Agent Barbie came along to lift my spirits, because it's pretty good. Probably the best game on the set overall, a decent little lite-stealth platformer that reminded me of the rather good Splinter Cell GBA games, though it's a lot easier and cheerier. Barbie in the 12 Dancing Princesses also seemed like a decent, basic little platformer with some lovely spritework. I have nothing much positive to say about any of the other included games. My discussion of their content is now finished. Time to get stuck into the real meat, here.

That last line seems pretty loaded to me.

See, there's a Dream House framing device to this whole thing - you're given an Unpacking-esque isometric home and a succession of furniture to decorate it with. The interface for doing so is tight, easily-readable and generally rather pleasant, while Barbie will pop in to chat to you over the phone and bless you with superb pixel art and a pleasingly witty script. And that's a lot better, isn't it? There's nothing at all tediously infantilising about the presentation of this mode. In fact, the whole thing frames the retrogaming contents of this package in such a way that it pointedly elevates itself above the material - not in condemnation, but - for the first time, I think - showcasing retro games with retro attitudes. Using the Dream House setup and its recall of the aforementioned mature indie classic Unpacking to challenge the player about how things used to be, how little was considered enough.

These thoughts all coalesced to create the impression in my glorious bald head that Barbie Rewind may actually be one of the most important game releases of the year. It's a vital and - honestly - somewhat moving demonstration of how far we've come. Of course, we could always go further, but this is far more than a throwaway cash grab. It's game preservation at its most important and relevant, with all the polish I've come to expect from a Digital Eclipse release. Bravo to them for making it and bravo to Atari for releasing it. I've entertained the possibility that maybe they themselves aren't aware of just how valuable a collection like this one really is. I certainly know how it made me feel. I won't be alone in that.